
Trust in Public Service Broadcasters: A comparison of the BBC and NHK
Trust in the BBC is sharply divided by political identity. Trust in Japan’s NHK follows a different pattern.
Communications
TrustTracker / Research themes
A public broadcaster can be a shared reference point—or a political dividing line. Our comparison of the BBC and NHK asks why trust in the news takes different forms in England and Japan.

Trust in the BBC is sharply divided by political alignment. NHK attracts a different pattern of political support.
The BBC sits close to traditional news in average trust. NHK scores below both traditional and social media news in Japan.
Our ongoing studies ask what people expect of impartial news and how those expectations connect to public-service funding.
Average BBC trust among respondents in England who reported voting for these three parties in the 2019 general election.
December 2022–June 2024. Descriptive, unweighted means calculated from the published replication data. Conservative n=3,999; Labour n=2,886; Liberal Democrat n=1,058. Other parties and unknown votes are omitted. Trust runs from 1 (lowest) to 7 (highest). This chart covers England; the paper separately compares the BBC with NHK in Japan.
Source: TrustTracker calculations from Pickering, Sunahara & Hansen (2025), replication data →
| 2019 vote | Mean BBC trust | Observations |
|---|---|---|
| Conservative | 3.17 | 3999 |
| Labour | 3.88 | 2886 |
| Liberal Democrat | 4.54 | 1058 |
For broadcasters, credibility has to be understood in relation to the audiences and political institutions around them. The comparison helps separate shared challenges from patterns particular to one country.

Trust in the BBC is sharply divided by political identity. Trust in Japan’s NHK follows a different pattern.
Communications

Academic freedom is a contested public good: ideology and trust shape public support in the UK and Japan.
Politics & Policy

High-salience elections can strengthen political trust. Evidence from Japan explores what changes when an election takes place.
Journal of Elections, Public Opinion and Parties
How can public service media remain credible across divided audiences? Our current BBC projects examine impartiality, legitimacy and funding.
What do people expect from impartial news, and how do those expectations relate to funding preferences? A BBC conjoint study examines the public foundations of public service broadcasting.
How do legitimacy and perceived public value shape preferences for BBC funding reform? This study examines public attitudes towards financing public service media in a changing media landscape.
A handbook chapter examines public attitudes towards academic freedom, comparing its social and political foundations in the UK and Japan.
Our commentary explores how political ideology and trust in expertise shape support for academic freedom.
Suzanne Hill interviews Steve Pickering about BBC trust and the implications for public service broadcasting.
Steve Pickering examines the BBC’s crisis of legitimacy through a comparison with Japan’s NHK.
Sabine Rennefanz draws on our findings to discuss political identity, public trust and the BBC controversy.
Our article explains the strong relationship between political identity and trust in the BBC.
Our comparison of the BBC and NHK examines why public broadcasting becomes politically contested.
Read about the survey design and research team, or access the data and replication code.
About the research → Open data & code →The original TrustTracker research programme was supported by the Japan Society for the Promotion of Science (JSPS, grant reference JPJSJRP 20211704) and the UK Research and Innovation's Economic and Social Research Council (UKRI-ESRC, grant reference ES/W011913/1).